
A look back at Etsy’s early homepage, when the marketplace was establishing itself as a destination for handmade goods.
Sellers and buyers have been wishing for an Etsy alternative, but is building a meaningful competitor possible at this stage?
With Etsy established as an e-commerce juggernaut, many sellers and shoppers have been wishing for an alternative online handmade marketplace. One that prioritizes handmade works, filters out dropshippers and enforces its AI policies.
GoImagine attempted to be an altruistic alternative to Etsy that was all about handmade, but the site shut down in March after six years. GoImagine had 7,200 sellers at its peak; for comparison, Etsy has 5.8 million active sellers and 87.5 million active buyers globally.
At this point in the game, is it realistic to expect a real competitor for Etsy to arise? Trying to compete with an $8.5 billion company is an expensive undertaking, to say the least. And does the world need another giant handmade online marketplace?
“There’s desire from sellers for such a marketplace, but is there desire from buyers?” wonders writer and craft organizer Kelly Rand. “That’s the biggest thing: Etsy has the eyeballs, and how do you get eyeballs if you don’t have the money to do TV spots and bus ads?”
The handmade monopoly
In its heyday, Etsy was “your place for handmade.” The site was launched in 2006 and by 2007 had 100,000 sellers, and by 2013 had surpassed 1 million.
Etsy’s growth was bolstered by buying up competitors such as Elo7 in Brazil, A Little Market in France, and absorbing Dawanda in Germany. The company went public in 2015, which meant that the company was beholden to stockholders expecting continuous growth.
In the pandemic, Etsy’s gross sales volume reached an all-time high of $12.2 billion in 2021. But long-running concerns about rising seller fees, dropshipping, and copyright infringement reached a head in 2022, when more than 20,000 sellers (out of 5.4 million) joined a strike, putting their stores in vacation mode for up to a week.
Samantha Close, Associate Professor of Media & Popular Culture at DePaul University, was involved with the Etsy strike.
“When we did our study of what crafters wanted in a platform, it didn’t look that dramatically different than Etsy,” Close says. “It was basically like, ‘no, we want Etsy, but we want it to work better.’”
Sellers wanted better support from the company and more opportunities for their concerns to be heard.
The Etsy Strike led some artisans to form a marketplace, Artisans Co-op, which allows only verified handmade sellers. About 65 sellers are part of the cooperative, which just exited beta this month. But the biggest issue in starting a peer-to-peer online market is getting a critical mass of customers; that’s what GoImagine struggled with.
“At the end of the day, if you don’t have the buyers, then you’re not going to have a business. GoImagine is probably the prime example of that, where they were much more optimized on the seller side,” says Liz Morton of Value Added Resource. “It becomes a which comes first, the chicken or the egg kind of thing. If you don’t have the buyers, you’re not going to have to get the sellers. If you don’t have the sellers, you’re not going to get the buyers.”
Etsy’s customer base has grown so large (87.5 million global shoppers as reported this quarter) that its main competitors are eBay and Amazon. Mainstream customers don’t care as much about discovery and curation as they do about free shipping and low prices.
By growing so large, Etsy has lost some of the special sauce that differentiated it on the market. “I think the risk for Etsy is not so much that some new marketplace is going to come up and become what Etsy used to be, but that by becoming more like everybody else, then everybody else becomes more of a competitor to Etsy,” Morton says.
Etsy followed the standard e-commerce playbook, Close says, focusing on free and fast shipping and favoring low prices and paid ads. “All of these are standard e-commerce things that work directly against handmade,” she says.
“The internet helped create the handmade movement, and that’s where Etsy flourished. with the advent of AI, with this new shopping reality that we’re barreling towards, it feels like there is room for another handmade movement of some kind.” Rand says. “I personally have not seen it yet, but I feel like I’ve been waiting for it.”
Changing customer expectations
The internet has changed vastly in the past 20 years — we are all constantly online but live in our own little algorithmic fiefdoms. It used to require effort to find something novel, whether it was a blog post, a video or a handmade object. Now we’re served up little delights all the time, and everything is shoppable.
Morton thinks that Etsy’s biggest competition is in live social selling on TikTok Shop and Whatnot, which have already taken big bites from eBay’s market in certain categories. “The reality is the e-commerce industry is going a lot more social. And I think that Etsy has not really provided a lot of opportunity for sellers to do that,” Morton says. “That’s an opportunity for Etsy or an Etsy competitor to say, ‘what would it look like to have maybe a Whatnot-type platform for crafts and handmade things?’”
Not every maker wants to hawk their wares live, and not all techniques are easy to film, but video is appealing to buyers who want to make sure the product they’re buying actually exists in the form advertised. (Side note: HSN and QVC’s parent company tried a social selling video app that included crafts, before closing it a year and a half later, and pivoting to focus on TikTok, where it was the seller of the year this year.)
AI agentic shopping is also changing the e-commerce game in ways that are still taking shape. AI agents want details, statistics and facts about products; that’s very different from the emotional marketing meant to appeal to humans.
“AI searches for the lowest common denominator currently. And fundamentally, that is at odds with what handmade is, because these are unique items and they are hard to discover on their own.” Rand says. “How do you take something that someone has created with hundreds of hours of craft knowledge and experience and love, their blood, sweat, and tears, and then reduce it to a set of numbers so an agentic shopper can find it? I don’t know.”
The potential for competition
It’s never been as easy to set up an online marketplace, and in a way that makes it even more difficult to build an audience. What distinguishes you from the millions of other online stores?
Creating a global two-way marketplace meant to compete with Etsy would require a massive amount of capital.
“If you think about Etsy, it wasn’t profitable for a very long time. And so you’re going to need a backer who is willing for it not to be profitable, and it’s going to be even harder since you’re not starting into a vacuum,” Close says.
Morton thinks it’s unlikely that a competitor could arise on the same scale as Etsy. “They’ve tried to go so broad that now they’re not differentiated as much anymore,” she says. “At a certain point, both buyers and sellers are looking at that and saying, well, why wouldn’t I just get this on eBay? Why wouldn’t I just get this on Poshmark?”
“I do think there’s opportunity. I think Etsy has allowed a lot to slip through their fingers,” Morton says. “I would love to see them focus more on the dropshipping problem. But now they have shareholders, they have growth they need to show. And so that creates incentives that are difficult to get beyond.”
Having a big alternative marketplace also wouldn’t automatically solve the issues plaguing Etsy. Screening potential sellers for quality is time-consuming and expensive, as is attracting a critical mass of shoppers who want to buy handmade.
“I see it as more likely that we’re going to get a plethora of very specially defined marketplaces,” Close says. Indeed, a few specialty sites have launched in the US this year: Fybe, which concentrates on fiber arts materials and goods, and StillSparkly, focusing on handmade, second-hand and vintage jewelry.

Handmade.com, backed by the team behind GoImagine and Novica, is emerging as a promising contender in the search for a more maker-focused alternative to Etsy.
With the ongoing global shipping and tariff issues, regional marketplaces have also grown in popularity in recent years. After Etsy bought A Little Market in 2017, some French makers started Un Grand Marche (“a big market), which has since grown to 30,000 sellers and more than 300,000 buyers in France.
Other notable regional handmade online marketplaces include:
- United Kingdom:Folksy and Makerville
- Southeast Asia:Pinkoi
- Japan:Minne, Creema and iichi
- Australia:MadeIt and Airehaus
Amazon Handmade, which still exists, isn’t a real alternative for buyers and sellers who are frustrated with Etsy’s corporatization and quality issues.
Shortly after GoImagine closed down, CEO Jon Lincoln and Creative Director Stephanie Romkey joined Handmade.com, a new endeavor that seems to hold a lot of promise. I recently spoke to CEO Roberto Milk, who started the online global artisan marketplace Novica.com in 1999, and he was clear in his intentions: “We want to be the better Etsy.”
Originally launched in partnership with National Geographic in 2000, Novica is the world’s largest fair trade artisan marketplace. Thousands of artisans in more than 100 countries sell with Novica via regional shipping hubs. Artisans deliver their products, and Novica polishes the descriptions and handles shipping — Milk describes it as a concierge two-sided marketplace.
With Handmade.com, they are first focusing on makers in the US for their two-sided marketplace, guided by Lincoln and Romkey’s experience at GoImagine. They are currently in beta, verifying that potential sellers are really the makers of the items.
“We admire what Etsy has done, but also things run away from you if you’re optimizing to just get someone on board really fast and you end up getting folks that may not be real,” Milk says.
They are creating a version of GoImagine’s Handmade Integrity Team, where marketplace sellers helped define categories and make decisions about the platform.
Milk says Novica moves about $20 million in gross merchandise volume annually, and the company has 150 employees, with substantial experience in e-commerce, SEO and logistics that will be used for Handmade.com. That’s a strong position to start from. In addition to pursuing partnerships to grow awareness with buyers, Milk wants Handmade.com to partner with local arts organizations and chambers of commerce across the US to build connections with makers.
“I think it will be essential for any marketplace that could rise up is that it needs to come from the community,” Close says. “Any businessperson is going to look at the Etsy situation and say there’s no point in trying to compete with a pre-existing monopoly.”
And there’s still a chance that Etsy could change. CEO Kruti Patel Goyal is less than a year into her tenure, but she has made some bold moves in shedding recent purchases like Depop and Reverb to focus more on the core Etsy marketplace.
Morton says, “Etsy could actually become the best Etsy competitor if they wanted to.”
*This article first appeared in our corporate members’ newsletter, Craft Industry Insider. Join orupgrade your membership to receive this newsletter each month.

Grace Dobush
contributor
Grace Dobush is a Berlin-based freelance journalist and the author of the Crafty Superstar business guides. Grace has written about business and creative entrepreneurship for publications including Fortune, Wired, Quartz, Handelsblatt and The Washington Post.

